Tuesday, March 8, 2016

Folly

Excerpt from Luther’s 95 Theses and Erasmus’s “Praise to Folly”

Luther’s 95 Theses:
• 27 They are wrong who say that the soul flies out of Purgatory as soon as the money thrown into the chest rattles.
• 32 Those who believe that, through letters of pardon [indulgences], they are made sure of their own salvation will be eternally damned along with their teachers.
• 37 Every true Christian, whether living or dead, has a share in all the benefits of Christ and of the Church, given by God, even without letters of pardon.
• 43 Christians should be taught that he who gives to a poor man, or lends to a needy man, does better than if he bought pardons.
• 44 Because by works of charity, charity increases, and the man becomes better; while by means of pardons, he does not become better, but only freer from punishment.
Page B3.120
• 45 Christians should be taught that he who sees any one in need, and, passing him by, gives money for pardons, is not purchasing for himself the indulgences of the Pope but the anger of God.
• 49 Christians should be taught that the Pope's pardons are useful if they do not put their trust in them, but most hurtful if through them they lose the fear of God.
• 50 Christians should be taught that if the Pope were acquainted with the exactions of the Preachers of pardons, he would prefer that the Basilica of St. Peter should be burnt to ashes rather than that it should be built up with the skin, flesh, and bones of his sheep.
• 54 Wrong is done to the Word of God when, in the same sermon, an equal or longer time is spent on pardons than on it.
• 62 The true treasure of the Church is the Holy Gospel of the glory and grace of God.
• 66 The treasures of indulgences are nets, wherewith they now fish for the riches of men.
• 67 Those indulgences which the preachers loudly proclaim to be the greatest graces, are seen to be truly such as regards the promotion of gain.
• 68 Yet they are in reality most insignificant when compared to the grace of God and the piety of the cross.
• 86 … why does not the Pope, whose riches are at this day more ample than those of the wealthiest of the wealthy, build the single Basilica of St. Peter with his own money rather than with that of poor believers? …
Luther’s Address to the German Nobility:
t has been devised that the Pope, bishops, priests, and
monks are called the spiritual estate; princes, lords,
artificers, and peasants are the temporal estate. This is
an artful lie and hypocritical device, but let no one be
made afraid by it, and that for this reason: that all
Christians are truly of the spiritual estate, and there is no
difference among them, save of office alone. As St. Paul
says (1 Cor.: 12), we are all one body, though each
member does its own work, to serve the others. This is
because we have one baptism, one Gospel, one faith, and
10 
are all Christians alike; for baptism, Gospel, and faith,
these alone make spiritual and Christian people.
As for the unction by a pope or a bishop, tonsure,
ordination, consecration, and clothes differing from those
of laymen—all this may make a hypocrite or an anointed
puppet, but never a Christian or a spiritual man. Thus we
are all consecrated as priests by baptism….
And to put the matter even more plainly, if a little
company of pious Christian laymen were taken prisoners
and carried away to a desert, and had not among them a
20 
priest consecrated by a bishop, and were there to agree to
elect one of them, born in wedlock or not, and were to
order him to baptise, to celebrate the mass, to absolve,
and to preach, this man would as truly be a priest, as if
all the bishops and all the popes had consecrated him.
That is why in cases of necessity every man can baptise
and absolve, which would not be possible if we were not
all priests….
[Members of the Church of Rome] alone pretend to be
considered masters of the Scriptures; although they learn
30 
nothing of them all their life. They assume authority, and
juggle before us with impudent words, saying that the
Pope cannot err in matters of faith, whether he be evil or
good, albeit they cannot prove it by a single letter. That is
why the canon law contains so many heretical and
unchristian, nay unnatural, laws….
And though they say that this authority was given
to St. Peter when the keys were given to him, it is plain
enough that the keys were not given to St. Peter alone,
Page B3.121
but to the whole community. Besides, the keys were not
40 
ordained for doctrine or authority, but for sin, to bind or
loose; and what they claim besides this from the keys is
mere invention….
Only consider the matter. They must needs
acknowledge that there are pious Christians among us
that have the true faith, spirit, understanding, word, and
mind of Christ: why then should we reject their word and
understanding, and follow a pope who has neither
understanding nor spirit? Surely this were to deny our
whole faith and the Christian Church….
50 
Therefore when need requires, and the Pope is a cause
of offence to Christendom, in these cases whoever can best
do so, as a faithful member of the whole body, must do
what he can to procure a true free council. This no one can
do so well as the temporal authorities, especially since
they are fellow-Christians, fellow-priests, sharing one
spirit and one power in all things,… Would it not be most
unnatural, if a fire were to break out in a city, and every
one were to keep still and let it burn on and on, whatever
might be burnt, simply because they had not the mayor's
60 
authority, or because the fire perchance broke out at the
mayor's house? Is not every citizen bound in this case to
rouse and call in the rest? How much more should this be
done in the spiritual city of Christ, if a fire of offence breaks
out, either at the Pope's government or wherever it may!
The like happens if an enemy attacks a town. The first to
rouse up the rest earns glory and thanks. Why then should
not he earn glory that decries the coming of our enemies
from hell and rouses and summons all Christians?
But as for their boasts of their authority, that no one
70 
must oppose it, this is idle talk. No one in Christendom
has any authority to do harm, or to forbid others to
prevent harm being done. There is no authority in the
Church but for reformation. Therefore if the Pope wished
to use his power to prevent the calling of a free council,
so as to prevent the reformation of the Church, we must
not respect him or his power; and if he should begin to
excommunicate and fulminate, we must despise this as
the doings of a madman, and, trusting in God,
excommunicate and repel him as best we may.

Erasmus “the Praise to Folly”

Now what else is the whole life of mortals but a sort of
comedy, in which the various actors, disguised by various
costumes and masks, walk on and play each one his
part, until the manager waves them off the stage?
Moreover, this manager frequently bids the same actor
go back in a different costume, so that he who has but
lately played the king in scarlet now acts the flunkey in
patched clothes. Thus all things are presented by
shadows; yet this play is put on in no other way….
[The disciplines] that approach nearest to common
10 
sense, that is, to folly, are held in highest esteem.
Theologians are starved, naturalists find cold comfort,
astrologers are mocked, and logicians are slighted….
Within the profession of medicine, furthermore, so far as
any member is eminently unlearned, impudent, or
careless, he is valued the more, even in the chambers of
belted earls. For medicine, especially as now practiced
by many, is but a subdivision of the art of flattery, no
less truly than is rhetoric. Lawyers have the next place
after doctors, and I do not know but that they should
20 
have first place; with great unanimity the philosophers—
not that I would say such a thing myself—are wont to
ridicule the law as an ass. Yet great matters and little
matters alike are settled by the arbitrament of these
asses. They gather goodly freeholds with broad acres,
while the theologian, after poring over chestfuls of the
great corpus of divinity, gnaws on bitter beans, at the
same time manfully waging war against lice and fleas. As
those arts are more successful which have the greatest
affinity with folly, so those people are by far the happiest
30 
who enjoy the privilege of avoiding all contact with the
learned disciplines, and who follow nature as their only
guide, since she is in no respect wanting, except as a
mortal wishes to transgress the limits set for his status.
Nature hates counterfeits; and that which is innocent of
art gets along far the more prosperously.
What need we say about practitioners in the arts? Self-love
is the hallmark of them all. You will find that they
would sooner give up their paternal acres than any piece
of their poor talents. Take particularly actors, singers,
40 
orators, and poets; the more unskilled one of them is,
the more insolent he will be in his self-satisfaction, the
more he will blow himself up…. Thus the worst art
pleases the most people, for the simple reason that the
larger part of mankind, as I said before, is subject to
folly. If, therefore, the less skilled man is more pleasing
both in his own eyes and in the wondering gaze of the
many, what reason is there that he should prefer sound
discipline and true skill? In the first place, these will
cost him a great outlay; in the second place, they will
50 
make him more affected and meticulous; and finally,
they will please far fewer of his audience….
And now I see that it is not only in individual men that
nature has implanted self-love. She implants a kind of it as
a common possession in the various races, and even
cities. By this token the English claim, besides a few other
things, good looks, music, and the best eating as their
special properties. The Scots flatter themselves on the
score of high birth and royal blood, not to mention their
dialectical skill. Frenchmen have taken all politeness for
60 
their province; though the Parisians, brushing all others
aside, also award themselves the prize for knowledge of
theology. The Italians usurp belles lettres and eloquence;
and they all flatter themselves upon the fact that they
alone, of all mortal men, are not barbarians. In this
particular point of happiness the Romans stand highest,
still dreaming pleasantly of ancient Rome. The Venetians
are blessed with a belief in their own nobility. The Greeks,
as well as being the founders of the learned disciplines,
vaunt themselves upon their titles to the famous heroes of
70 
old. The Turks, and that whole rabble of the truly
barbarous, claim praise for their religion, laughing at
Christians as superstitious….
[Next come] the scientists, reverenced for their beards
and the fur on their gowns, who teach that they alone are
wise while the rest of mortal men flit about as shadows.
How pleasantly they dote, indeed, while they construct
their numberless worlds, and measure the sun, moon,
stars, and spheres as with thumb and line. They assign
causes for lightning, winds, eclipses, and other
80 
inexplicable things, never hesitating a whit, as if they
were privy to the secrets of nature, artificer of things, or
as if they visited us fresh from the council of the gods. Yet
all the while nature is laughing grandly at them and their
conjectures. For to prove that they have good intelligence
of nothing, this is a sufficient argument: they can never
explain why they disagree with each other on every
subject. Thus knowing nothing in general, they profess to
know all things in particular; though they are ignorant even
of themselves, and on occasion do not see the ditch or the
90 
stone lying across their path, because many of them are
blear-eyed or absent-minded; yet they proclaim that they
perceive ideas, universals, forms without matter….
Page B3.133
Perhaps it were better to pass over the theologians in
silence, [for] they may attack me with six hundred
arguments, in squadrons, and drive me to make a
recantation; which if I refuse, they will straightway
proclaim me an heretic. By this thunderbolt they are wont
to terrify any toward whom they are ill-disposed.
They are happy in their self-love, and as if they already
100 
inhabited the third heaven they look down from a height
on all other mortal men as on creatures that crawl on the
ground, and they come near to pitying them. They are
protected by a wall of scholastic definitions, arguments,
corollaries, implicit and explicit propositions; … they
explain as pleases them the most arcane matters, such as
by what method the world was founded and set in order,
through what conduits original sin has been passed down
along the generations, by what means, in what measure,
and how long the perfect Christ was in the Virgin's womb,
110 
and how accidents subsist in the Eucharist without their
subject.
But those are hackneyed. Here are questions worthy of
the great and (as some call them) illuminated theologians,
questions to make them prick up their ears—if ever they
chance upon them. Whether divine generation took place
at a particular time? Whether there are several sonships
in Christ? Whether this is a possible proposition: God the
Father hates the Son? Whether God could have taken
upon Himself the likeness of a woman? Or of a devil? Of an
120 
ass? Of a gourd? Of a piece of flint? Then how would that
gourd have preached, performed miracles, or been
crucified?….
Coming nearest to these in felicity are the men who
generally call themselves “the religious” and “monks”—
utterly false names both, since most of them keep as far
away as they can from religion and no people are more in
evidence in every sort of place…. For one thing, they
reckon it the highest degree of piety to have no contact
with literature, and hence they see to it that they do not
130 
know how to read. For another, when with asinine voices
they bray out in church those psalms they have learned,
by rote rather than by heart, they are convinced that they
are anointing God's ears with the blandest of oil. Some of
them make a good profit from their dirtiness and
mendicancy, collecting their food from door to door with
importunate bellowing; nay, there is not an inn, public
conveyance, or ship where they do not intrude, to the
great disadvantage of the other common beggars. Yet
according to their account, by their very dirtiness,
140 
ignorance, these delightful fellows are representing to us
the lives of the apostles.

Saturday, February 6, 2016

Chapter 5 Synthesis: The Rise of the West ca. 500-1100

The thousand-year period between the fall of the Roman Empire ( 4 76 c. E.) and the European Renaissance (ca. 1400) is generally known as "the Middle Ages." Synthesis (the combining of individual parts to form a whole) describes the first phase of this era, roughly 500 to 1100 c.E., when three distinctive cultures-Classical, Christian, and Germanic came together to fuel the rise of the West. In the territories that would come to be called "Europe," the geographic contours of modern Western states took shape. Isolated from the rest of the world by the westward expansion of Islam, early medieval culture generated unique political, religious, and linguistic traditions that survive today.
The empire created by the Germanic chieftain Charlemagne (Charles the Great) provides an excellent example of the process of synthesis that characterized the rise of the West. Carolingian culture integrated Classical. Christian, and Germanic traditions to form the fabric of medieval life. Feudalism, a political and military system, established patterns of social rank and status that dominated early medieval society. The landmark artworks of this period are animated by a spirit of rugged warfare, the bonds of feudal loyalty, and a rising tide of Christian piety and belief.

A First Look
The Bayeux Tapestry is a unique record of a
major historical event: the Norman conquest of
England. This landmark artwork is not, in fact,
a woven tapestry, but an embroidery, created
to ornament a banquet hall or to line the choir
walls of Bayeux Cathedral in northwestern
France. Sewn into a roll of bleached linen cloth,
some 20 inches high and 231 feet long-two thirds
the length of a football field-the lively
visual narrative chronicles the incidents leading
up to and including the Battle of Hastings, the
outcome of which gave William of Normandy
control of England in 1066. Some seventy-nine
scenes unroll continuously, in the manner of an
ancient parchment scroll, a Roman historical
narrative (see Figure 3.14), or a modern comic
strip. Above and alongside each scene, Latin
captions idenify the characters, places, and
events. Real and imaginary birds and animals
populate the borders above and below, and
in the battle scenes, fallen warriors clutter the
earth. Epic in scope and robust in style, the
Bayeux Tapestry presents a picture of an age
in which Christianity became a militant force
in the West. It provides a vivid visual record
of feudal life, colored by scenes of combat that
constitute a veritable encyclopedia of medieval
battle gear (seen in this detail): kite-shaped
shields, conical iron helmets, chain mail, battle
axes, and double-edged swords.

THE GERMANIC TRIBES
THE Germanic peoples were a tribal folk who followed a
migratory existence. Dependent on their flocks and herds,
they lived in pre-urban village communities throughout
Asia and frequently raided and plundered nearby lands
for material gain; yet they settled no territorial state. As
early as the first century B.C.E., a loose confederacy of
Germanic tribes began to threaten Roman territories, but
it was not until the fourth century C.E. that these tribes,
driven westward by the fierce Central Asian nomads
known as Huns, pressed into the Roman Empire. Lacking
the hallmarks of civilization-urban settlements, monumental
architecture, and the art of writing-the Germanic
tribes struck the Romans as inferiors, as outsiders, hence,
as "barbarians."
The Germanic language family, dialects of which differed
from tribe to tribe, included East Goths (Ostrogoths),
West Goths (Visigoths), Franks, Vandals, Burgundians,
Angles, and Saxons-to name but a few. The Ostrogoths
occupied the steppe region between the Black and Baltic
seas, while the Visigoths settled in territories closer to the
Danube River (Map 5.1). As the tribes pressed westward,
an uneasy alliance was forged: The Romans allowed them
to settle on the borders of the Empire, but in exchange the
Germanic warriors had to afford Rome protection against
other invaders. Antagonism between Rome and the West
Toths led to a military showdown.  At the Battle of Adriantinople, near modern
Edirne in Turkey) in 3378 CE, the Visigoths defeated teh "invincible" Roman army, killing the East Roman Emperor Valens and dispersing his army.   Almost immediately thereafter, the Visigoths swept  across the Roman border, raiding the cities of the declining West, including Rome itself in 410 CE.

Germanic Culture
Germanic culture differed dramatically from that of Rome: In the agrarian and essentially self-sufficient communities of these nomadic peoples, fighting was a way of life and a highly respected skill.  Armed with javelins and shields, Germanic warriors fought fiercely both on foot and on horseback. Superb horsemen, the Germanic calvary would come to borrow from the Mongols spurs and foot stirrups-devices (originating~ China) that firmly
secured the rider in his saddle and improved his driving
force. In addition to introducing to the West superior
methods of fighting on horseback, the Germanic tribes
imposed their own longstanding traditions on medieval
Europe. Every Germanic chieftain retained a band of
warriors that followed him into battle, and every warrior
anticipated sharing with his chieftain the spoils of victory.
The bond of fealty, or loyalty between the Germanic
warrior and his chieftain, and the practice of rewarding
the warrior would become fundamental to the medieval
practice of feudalism.
Germanic law was not legislated by the state, as in
Roman tradition, but was, rather, a collection of customs
passed orally from generation to generation. The Germanic
dependence on custom would have a lasting influence
on the development of Jaw, and especially common law,
in parts of the West. As in most ancient societies-Hammurabi's
Babylon, for instance-penalties for crimes varied
according to the social standing of the guilty party.
Among the Germanic tribes, however, a person's guilt
or innocence might be determined by an ordeal involving
fire or water; such trials reflected the faith Germanic
peoples placed in the will of nature deities. Some of the
names of these gods came to designate days of the week;
for example, the English word "Wednesday" derives from
"Woden's day" and "Thursday" from ''Thor's day."

Germanic Literature
Germanic traditions, including those of personal valor
and heroism associated with a warring culture, are
reflected in the epic poems of the early Middle Ages. The
three most famous of these, Beowulf, The
Song of the Nibelungs, and The Song of
Roland, were transmitted orally for hundreds
of years before they were written down sometime
between the tenth and thirteenth centuries. Beowulf originated
among the Anglo-Saxons and was recorded in Old
English-the Germanic language spoken in part of the
British Isles between the fifth and eleventh centuries. The
Song of the Nibelungs, a product of the Burgundian tribes,
was recorded in Old German; and the Frankish Song of
Roland, in Old French. Celebrating the deeds of warrior-heroes,
these three epic poems have much in common
with the Iliad, the Mahabharatn, and other orally transmitted
adventure poems.

The three-thousand-line epic known as Beowulf is
the first monumental literary composition in a European
vernacular language-the everyday language of
the people. The tale of a daring Scandinavian prince,
Beowulf brings to life the heroic world of the Germanic
people with whom it originated. In unrhymed Old English
verse embellished with numerous two-term metaphors
known as kennings ("whale-path" for "sea,"
"ring-giver" for "king''), the poem recounts three major
adventures: Beowulf's encounter with the monster Grendel
his destruction of Grendel's hideous and vengeful
' mother, and (some five decades later) his efforts to
destroy the fire-breathing dragon that threatens his people.
These adventures-the stuff of legend, folk tale, and
fantasy-immortalize the mythic origins of the Anglo-Saxons.
Composed in the newly Christianized England of the eighth
century, the poem was not written down for another two centuries.

Germanic Art
The artistic production of nomadic peoples consists
largely of easily transported objects such as carpets,
jewelry, and weapons. Germanic folk often buried the
most lavish of these items with their chieftains in boats
that were cast out to sea (as described in Beowulf). In 1939,
archeologists at Sutton Hoo in eastern England excavated
a seventh-century C.E. Anglo-Saxon grave that contained
weapons, coins, utensils, jewelry, and a small lyre. These
landmark treasures were packed, along with the corpse
of the chieftain, into an 89-foot-long ship that served as a
tomb. Among the remarkable metalwork items found at
Sutton Hoo was a 5-pound gold belt buckle richly ornamet,
ted with a dense pattern of interlaced snakes with
beaked, birdlike heads (Figure 5.2). The high quality of
so-called ''barbarian" art, as evidenced at Sutton Hoo
and elsewhere, shows that technical sophistication and
artistic originality were by no means the monopoly of
"civilized" societies. Such artifacts also demonstrate the
continuous diffusion and exchange of styles across Asia
and into Europe.
As the Germanic tribes poured into Europe, their
art and their culture comingled with that of the people
with whom they came into contact. A classic example is
the fusion of Celtic and Anglo-Saxon styles. The Celts
were a non-Germanic, Iron Age folk that had migrated
throughout Europe between the fifth and third centuries
B.C.E., settling in the British Isles before the time of Jesus.
A great flowering of Celtic art and literature occurred in
Ireland and England following the conversion of the Celts
to Christianity in the fifth century C.E. The instrument of
this conversion was the fabled Patrick (ca. 385-461 C.E.),
the British monk who is said to have baptized more than
120,000 people and founded three hundred churches in
Ireland, for which he is revered as Ireland's patron saint.
In the centuries thereafter, Anglo-Irish monasteries produced
a number of extraordinary Christian manuscripts,
whose decorative style is closely related to the dynamic
linear ornamentation of the Sutton Hoo artifacts.
The Germanic ornamental vocabulary influenced not
only the illumination of Christian manuscripts but also
the decoration of Christian liturgical objects, such as the
paten (Eucharistic plate) and the chalice (Eucharistic
cup). Used in the celebration of the Mass, these objects
usually commanded the finest and most costly materials;
and, like the manuscripts prepared for the sacred
rite itself, they received inordinate care in their execution.
Even as the Germanic tribes slowly converted to
Christianity, Germanic art entered the mainstream of
medieval art, where it fused with Greco-Roman artforms
to flower eventually in the great age of cathedrals (see
pages 157-164).

The Age of Charlemagne
FROM the time he came to the throne in 768 C. E., until
his death in 814 C.E., the Frankish chieftain Charles
the Great (in French, "Charlemagne"; Figure 5.4)
pursued the dream of restoring the Roman
Empire under Christian leadership. A
great warrior and an able administrator,
the fair-haired heir to the Frankish
kingdom conquered vast areas of land
in what would later come to be called
"Europe" (Map 5.2). His holy wars the
Christian equivalent of the Muslim
jihad- resulted in the forcible conversion
of the Saxons east of the Rhine River,
the Lombards of northern Italy, and the
Slavic peoples along the Danube. Charlemagne's
campaigns also pushed the
Muslims back beyond the Pyrenees
into Spain.
In the year 800 C. E., Pope Leo III crowned
Charlemagne "Emperor of the Romans,"
thus establishing a firm relationship between
Church and state. But, equally significant!~
Charlemagne's role in creating a Roman
Christian or "Holy" Roman Empire cast him as the prototype
of Christian kingship. For the more than thirty years
during which he waged wars in the name of Christ,
Charlemagne sought to control conquered lands by placing
them in the hands of local administrators-on whom
he bestowed the titles "count" and "duke"-and by
periodically sending out royal envoys to carry his edicts
abroad. He revived trade with the East, stabilized
the currency of the realm, and even pursued diplomatic
ties with Baghdad, whose caliph, Harun
al-Rashid, graced Charlemagne's court with the
gift of an elephant.

The Carolingian Renaissance
Charlemagne's imperial mission was driven
by a passionate interest in education and the
arts. Like most Germanic warrior chieftains,
Charlemagne could barely read and write- his
sword hand was, according to his biographers,
so callused that he had great difficulty forming letters.
Nevertheless, admiring his Classical predecessors, he sponsored the
Carolingian (from Carolus, Latin for Charles) renaissance, or rebirth, of learning and literacy. To oversee his educational program, he invited to his court missionaries and scholars from all over Europe. The most notable
of these was Alcuin of York, an Anglo-Saxon monk whose
work as a teacher and translator fostered a glorious revival
of learning. With Alcuin's assistance, Charlemagne established
a school at his palace in Aachen (see Map 5.2), and
similar schools at Benedictine monasteries throughout the
Empire.
Here, monks and nuns copied religious manuscripts,
along with Classical texts on medicine, drama, and other
secular subjects. Carolingian copyists replaced the difficult to
decipher Roman script, which lacked punctuation and spaces
between words, with a neat, uniform writing style known as
the Carolingian minuscule-the model for modem typography.
The long-term importance of Charlemagne's renaissance is
best reflected in the fact that 80 percent of our oldest Classical
Latin manuscripts survive in Carolingian copies.

Map 5.1

Map 5.2


Sunday, January 31, 2016

Literature Part 2

Literature Part 2
Satire, poetic. Roman Classical Era. Juvenal and the Thirteen Bitter Satires:
Romans also mastered the field of poetic satire, a genre that had an enormous success among the general populace. Satire, in general, uses humor, irony, and paradigm to point out human foibles and flaws. Roman irony shows the contradiction between the literal and intended meaning. Roman satire also shows human imperfection through great comical humor. This gave way in the visual arts to caricature – the exaggeration of peculiarities and defects, whether physical or mental – of human beings. This clearly gave way one of Rome’smost aggressive forms of arts, graffiti.
The most popular satirist in early imperial Rome was Juvenal (60-130AD), the most violent and devastating in his satirical compositions. Some of this attitude most have been produced by previous failures in life – he was born to a family of freed slaves, he failed to become a magistrate, abandoned by his wife, he experienced poverty – this must have given to him a negative perception of Roman society, at times exaggerated, but alsoconsidered as one of the most important sources of information regarding the new social asset of Romeduring the imperial era, when compared to the virtues of the Republic.
Juvenal, engraving
His sixteen bitter satires indicate that the Romans had degenerated. His satires show a deep criticism of the Romans’ descent into luxury and easy life styles. In his “Against Rome” he paints a picture of the city as being noisy, dirty, a crowded community of selfish, violent and self-indulgent people.
(Book 3 – Against Rome)
(the “new” poor and the “new rich in early imperial Rome)
“If you’re poor, you’re a joke, on each and every occasion.
What a laugh, if your cloak is dirty or torn, if your toga
Seems a little bit soiled, if your shoe has a crack in the leather,
Or if more than one patch attests to more than one mending!
Poverty’s greatest curse, much worse than the fact of it, is that
It makes men objects of mirth, ridiculed, humbled, embarrassed.
‘Out of the front-row seats!’ they cry when you’re out of money,
Yield your place to the sons of some pimp, the spawn of some cathouse,
Some slick auctioneer’s brat, or the louts some trainer has fathered
Or the well-groomed boys whose sire is a gladiator”.
Clearly, Juvenal attests that the values of the Republic – a government that showed concern for the lower classes – are gone. But it also depicts the rise of new wealthy groups that derive from classes that during the Republican era were among the lowest and most ignorant.
Graffiti found in Rome dating to the early period of Christianity.
Juvenal also gives us an idea of the overcrowded city of RomeThis rapid influx of people into the imperial capital created problems for many; unemployment, underemployment, disease, poverty, crime, housing was in high demand and short supply, and rents were steep. He describes how most Romans now lived in statesponsored multistory apartment blocks known as insulae; literally “islands” away from the wealthy center, housing about 80% of Rome’s population. They were basically tenements, with shops on the ground floors, and living quarters on top. They could rise to heights of 60’-70’, but were built of inadequate framework, the walls were as thin as paper, rat infested, land lords added upper rooms on the terrace making the structure more delicate, plumbing was never enough, and they were prone to set fire easily. Noise and hygiene were an enormous problem, as people dumped bodily wastes from the pots directly out of the window and onto the road, as Juvenal states:
“You can suffer as many deaths as there are open windows to pass under. So offer a prayer that people will be content with just emptying out their slop bowls.”
In describing social decay, in his view, nothing is more evident than his Against Women,” where he laments the disappearance of the chaste Latin republican woman and her virtues, in contrast with the new frivolous, luxury-living, political engaging imperial women, devoted to lust and not their domestic duties. Was Juvenal maybe jealous of women in the imperial era?
Roman Insula - apartment building, 100 AD circa.
Women were sufficiently well educated and many were literate during the imperial era. Not to forget, that many aristocratic women could engage indirectly in politics by advising their son’s career, especially if the latter was on his way to a position of magistrate, senator, or emperor (see Nero and his influential motherAgrippina).
During the Republic a woman’s status was different. Women had no legal, civil, or juridical rights, they were always subject to the male authority of the family, and could receive orders from their father and brother in law as well. Women could not own property, and they even had to ask the permission of the husband – or makerelative – to write a simple contract.. Yet her duties were important not only for the family but also for the state.The “materfamilias” that Juvenal yearns for is gone with the rise of the empire. During the republic she held the keys to the storerooms, she kept track of expenditures and purchases (she was a secretary); she supervised the workmanship of the slaves and clients, she processed foods, and strictly overlooked the raising of her children.
Excerpt from Juvenal – see excerpts Juvenal
See also Power Points and Videos - Juvenal
Satire: Reformation. Erasmus of Rotterdam. The Praise to Folly
The powerful Medieval Church had called itself Catholic, which means “Universal”. In the hands of reformers, the term came to indicate more and more the Catholic Church of Rome, which already during the late Middle Ages, came under increasing attacks and criticism. Medieval critics questioned some of the beliefs and practices of the church – its power and wealth – and its insistence that obedience to the Pope was necessary for salvation. In the early Modern Era these critics grew mainly in Northern Europe and were known asChristian Humanists. In the fifteenth-century leaders in the Netherlands launched a movement known as the“Devotio moderna” (Modern Devotion). Lay men and women met in private “Comparative World Cultures, Religions, and Criticisms:homes to read and interpret holy scriptures. In Germany, Thomas Kempis published the “Imitatio Christi” “Comparative World Cultures, Religions, and Criticisms: (Imitation of Christ), bringing the message of Christ into the daily life and widely published throughout Europe.
Europe 1550 AD circa
This movement was noticeable in Germany, where differently from Italian Humanists – which studied the Pagan classics – German humanists preferred the study and translation of Christian manuscriptsBible and the writings of the founding fathers of the Latin Church. They revived the values of early Christian life. Among them, the prince of all Christian humanists was by far Desiderius Erasmus of Rotterdam; learned in Latin and Greek, he was a pure neo-classicist, a devout Christian who preached for a return to the basic teachings of Christ and made wide use of the printing press to publicize his ideas. He also introduced a critical edition of the New Testament that corrected the mistranslations of Jerome’s translation – from Greek to Latin – in biblical passages.
Luther: In 1517, the German Augustinian monk, Martin Luther (pg. 473-479), a product of Christian Humanism and a doctor in theology, touched off a revolution that will rock the foundations of the Papal Roman Church: when Luther drew up the 95 Theses for debate and hammered them on the door of the church of Wittenberg.In them he questioned church practices, specifically the practice of granting indulgences, a practice by which Church authorities forgiveness of sin and remission of punishment by recognizing certain pious acts performed by people: such a pious act was often a donation of money to Church authorities, a practice that matured during the medieval Crusades. The granting of indulgences became so popular that it allowed the Church to finance the construction of St. Peter’s Basilica!
According to Luther salvation is not obtained through good deeds or grace mediated by the Church, and stimulated by his readings of Paul’s epistles he came
to the conclusion that “faith” alone saves the individual: Justification by Faith“the just shall live by faith” (Romans 1:17). For example, point 27 of the 95 Theses, “They are wrong who say that the soul flies out of Purgatory as soon as the money thrown into the chest rattle”; and again, point 37 “Every true Christian, whether living or dead, has a share in all the benefits of Christ and of the Church, given by God, even without letters of pardon”. In fact, for Luther, Christ’s sacrifice had been one, complete and good for all times. Martin Luther, portrait by Lucas Cranach the Elder
The Christian didn’t really need anything else for his own salvation. Furthermore, he found justification in scripture for only two of the seven sacraments dispensed by the Church, Communion and Baptism, and rejected the other five. And finally, he attacked priesthood and monasticism, denied the Pope as being the vicar of Christ, and rejected relics and beatification of saints; point 50 “Christians should be taught that the Pope’s pardons are useful if they do not put their trust in them, but most hurtful if through them they lose the fear of God”. Therefore, faith alone, says Luther, and not good deeds, are necessary for salvation, and this remains at the core of Protestantism.
Nevertheless, Luther didn’t want to destroy the Catholic Church of Rome, but rather, reform it. Luther’s challenge, however, produced a storm within the Church that eventually drove him to reject some Catholic doctrine and organize his own Protestant Church. He will be excommunicated in 1520 by Pope Leo X, and then summoned to the Council of Worms in 1521, to defend himself from the accusation of heresy. At the Council he was protected by many German Princes, in particular, he remained under protection of the Duke of Saxony, a German Lord eager to defect from RomeIt’s under his protection that Luther spent the next four years in translating the New Testament from Latin to German. Our text, Reading 19.1 – Address to the German Nobility – clearly shows that many German leaders supported Luther’s challenge because they viewed it as an opportunity to avoid Papal Church intervention in their political affairs, as well as the Pope’s constant taxation of Germanic principalities. Furthermore, it gave the German nobility to recede their legacies with the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, a faithful Catholic. And finally, many Catholics sympathized with the need to reform.
Pope Leo X, portrait by Raffaello.
Luther’s Doctrine of “Justification by Faith” had widespread appeal. Moreover, many Catholics sympathized with the need of reform. Although the Holy Roman Emperor, the Spaniard Charles V fought Protestantism, he was distracted by many other concerns of his huge Empire – including Spain, Austria and the Germanic States. In 1555, following a series of religious/civil wars, he was obliged to accept the Peace Treaty of Augsburg that recognized the right of each Prince to determine whether his realm would be Catholic or Lutheran “Cuius Regio eius Religio”. The peace did not, however, recognize any other Protestant groups. Nevertheless, other movements of Catholic rejection grew throughout Europe reinforcing altogether the Protestant movement. For example, the 1524 Peasant’s Revolt in Germany, led by liberal, anti-catholic commoners, to the rise of Calvinism and Anabaptism in Switzerland.
Erasmus of Rotterdam (1466-1536): The greatest Christian humanist – that followed the above mentioned intentions - was Desiderius Erasmus of Rotterdam (1466-1536), who became known as the “Prince of humanists”It is said that Erasmus laid down the egg that Luther will hatch. Erasmus knew firsthand that the church needed reform, because he was born in Holland as the illegitimate son of a supposedly celibate priest. In fact, he dropped out of school complaining that the University offered “theology as stale as their eggs”. He moves to England and becomes friend of Thomas More and based his curriculum humanistic studies there.He learned Greek so he could immerse himself in the mental world of the New Testament.
ALBRECHT DÜRER, Erasmus of Rotterdam, 1526. Engraving, 9¾ × 7½ in. The Latin inscription at the top of the engraving reports that Dürer executed the portrait from life. The Greek inscription below reads, “The better image [is found] in his writings.”
His greatest contribution to the intellectual life of the West was his critical edition of the New Testament. To approach this, Erasmus rejected the officially accepted version of the bible – Jerome’s Latin translation – and returned to the Greek and Hebrew textsHe insisted that people should read the bible on their own – without the intermediation of priests – and possibly in Greek to understand its true essence. Most of all, he used satire to criticize corruption in the Church. His most famous satire was the Praise to Folly (reading 19.2); in it he attacked a wide variety of human foibles, including greed, intellectual pomposity and pride. Most of all his attacks also probed deeply into many of the religious and professional practices of the day, and as readers laughed at his attacks on those people who worshipped the Virgin over her son and the popes who didn’t live like Jesus, or physicians incapable of diagnosing a fever, their ideas on the church as well as religion, and the privileged began to change.
He dedicated this opera to his good friend, Thomas More (Latin Moria means Folly). The Praise to Folly opens with a world resembling a large theatrical stageDame Folly, the allegorical figure of this writing, is the speaker of the opera, and she compares life to a comedy, in which players assume several roles. Through the device of Folly, therefore, Erasmus is free to say anything he pleases. Erasmus spares virtually no one among Folly’s “regiment of fools”, least of all the Theologians and Church officials (lines 94 to 142 in Reading 19.2).he attacks, especially, those who “maintain the cheat of pardons and indulgences”, a sentiment that, as we know, would have influenced Martin Luther. Nevertheless, although a strident critic of the papacy, Erasmus remained committed to the Church throughout his life. He was a monk but also a Humanist scholar remaining committed to beauty as the flowers in the vase in the engraving portrait executed by Durer, attests (see fig. 19.3).
Excerpt from Luther’s 95 Theses and Erasmus’s “Praise to Folly – see excerpts Luther and Erasmus
Satire: Scientific Revolution and the Enlightenment. Voltaire. Candide
Scientific Revolution: The 17th century was an age of intellectual and scientific ferment, dominated by France, Holland, Italy and England, it set the foundations of Contemporary Rationalism. It is the age of the Scientific Revolution. During the 17th century there was a passage from a society based on religious certainties to one based on secular-scientific concerns. The pace was uneven, it differed from place to place, and for most people religion remained at the root of human concern, since salvation was still the desired end of life. To say the truth, both Catholics and Protestants seemed appalled at many of the discoveries, since they seemed to challenge the authority of Scripture. Also problematic for both religions were new methods of reasoning that challenged the place of faith in arriving at an understanding of the universe. And in fact, in the seventeenth-century newly invented instruments allowed scientists to observe and measure natural phenomena withincreasing accuracy: faith was not set aside, but placed in a different branch of
The Heliocentric Theory proposed by Copernicus in 1453, giving way to the ntoion of a sun centered universe versus the geocentric theory, earth centered.
knowledge.
The scientific revolution was based in undermining the old world view still impinged on Aristotelian science, that is, the cosmological understanding of an earth-centered universe (see fig. 23.2). A concept, not only proposed by Aristotle, but “hammered” by the second-century AD Alexandrian scientist Ptolemy in his text Almagest (a favorite among Medieval thinkers).
Altogether, the scientists of the seventeenth-century deferred from their Medieval predecessors in asserting that “Scientia” (knowledge in Latin) operates separately from God’s dominion. Medieval thinkers viewed the universe and its movements as nothing else than the extension of god’s divine power. The rationalist of the 17th C. viewed the universe as operating according to mathematical laws that could be understood by the human mind. In simple terms, the scientists of the 17th C. moved nature from the hands of monks and priests into the hands of laboratories.
The Baroque era, in fact, witnessed this almost empirical attention to the natural world; in art, most noticeable, is the application of real light in well defined space, and an increased wanting for figures that revealed every day experience: landscape, portraiture, still life, and domestic settings. The Scientific Revolution had an enormous effect not only on the visual arts - with the inventions of new instruments coming from the scientific world to perfect detail – but also on the rise of new and better performing musical compositions and instruments.
https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSa02FktjkKaVMMIti5yqVfInInDtKrhyBg0SYvon7zaIDZ_oqCmgScience will become a profession in the 17th century. And although a true conflict between science and religion didn’t really exist, the scientific revolution launched by the Italians Giordano Bruno, Marco Coronelli and Galileo Galilei, the Englishmen Newton, Bacon, Harvey and Boyle, and Frenchmen Des Cartes and Pascal, moved steadily the world towards secularism and man’s domination of natural phenomena. As an American philosopher will say, Norm whitehead “we have been living upon the accumulated capital of ideas provided…by the genius of the seventeenth century.
Galileo's refracting telescope. New instruments such as the telescope allowed scientists observe with greater and detail and measure with greater precision natural phenomena.
The new empirical approach to the world had also a great impact on the evolution of satirical writings that aggressively attacked the deductive and erroneous opinions regarding the world and politics that had been dominated by Church and dogmatism world and natural events.
The Enlightenment and the Satire of Voltaire: Reason, Natural Law, Progress, these were the key terms by the eighteenth-century. It was the Age of Enlightenment, when it was widely assumed that human reason could cure the ills of the past and help achieve utopian modern democratic governments, perpetual peace and a perfect society. Reason would enable humanity to discover the rules of nature that regulate our existence and thereby assure progress. The intellectuals who professed this creed were known as PhilosophesThey included critics, publicists, economists, political scientists, and social reformers. On the whole the Enlightenment was based on the fact that people could correct the error of their ways once those errors had been pointed out to them. The principle preoccupation of the Enlightenment thinkers was the comprehension of human nature in scientific terms – without reference to divine authority. It is no wonder that during this time we have the rise of modern social sciences; from sociology, psychology to anthropology. And finally, Many Enlightened thinkers developed and articulated the fundamental concepts of natural law, political freedom, free enterprise, and the social contract between ruler and ruled: in France and North America they “fanned” the flames of revolt, culminating in violent revolutions.
Enlightenment and Religion: For the most part, the thinkers of the Enlightenment were deist, and therefore, believed in religious tolerance. Deist doctrines arose in late seventeenth-century England, where the deists hoped to settle religious strife by reason rather than by arms. All persons, they asserted, could agree on a few broad religious principles.
N. LAVRÉINCE, Assembly in a Salon, 1745–1807. Oil on canvas, 1¾ × 2 ft. The painting shows the elegantly dressed men and women of eighteenth-century society enjoying leisure activities in the salon of a Parisian townhouse. Arts, philosophy, science and playing music were freely practiced in these salons. This shows young Mozart exhibiting himself while playing the clavichord blindfolded.
They accepted that God had created the universe but didn’t believe he had much, if anything, to do with its day-to-day working. Rather, the universe proceeded according to what they termed natural law, law derived from nature and binding upon society. In Newtonian terms, God had created a great clock, and it ran like clockwork, except for the interference of inept humanity. They believed in the immortality of the soul, not in a dogmatic sense, but because they regarded human beings unique and different from other living creatures.They viewed the bible as mythology and full of superstition, they showed aversion to irrationality, which, according to many, was implicit in Christian dogma (especially the “non sense” - as they termed it – of the Original Sin). This made them anti-clericalshowing enoprmo0us antipathy for the Catholic Church of Rome, and this resulted sometimes in the persecution of many Philosophes (remember the “Illuminati”? They were all deists). Voltaire, maybe the most powerful mind of the eighteenth-century, declared, “men will not be free until the last king will be strangled with the entrails of the last priest.” Such concepts will be actually imposed by the republican governments of Revolutionary France at the end of the eighteenth-century.
*The Pilosophes derived their principles from the writers and scientists of the preceding age of genius. Their faith in Natural Science came from Newton, and their confidence of the power of human reason in part to Rene’ Descartes. But it was John Locke to whom the rationalists turned to in the field of politics. In his “Of Civil Government”, Locke professed that all people are by nature born free, equal and independent and that they submit to government always because they find it convenient to do so.
Satire: It became the weapon of the Enlightenment. Cultural trends were still controlled by political powers that remained blind to the new progressive ideas of the Philosophes; they in turn responded to this by writing biting literary satireIn fact, the 18th C. was the greatest era in the history of satire. Satire used irony and paradigm to attack human ignorance and foiblesJuvenal in ancient imperial Rome used it to attack political realities;Erasmus of Rotterdam used it to criticize the Catholic Church so that it would re-moralize and reform its assets.
Voltaire (1648-1778): The chief exponent of the enlightenment, as well as of Deism and anti-clericalism in the France and in Europe was Francois Arouet, Voltaire. Born in Paris to a middle class family he was educated by Jesuits. He poured forth letter, epics, plays, often brightly satirical, he was viewed by authorities as being so subversive that he often had to elude authorities by printing with different names (twice he was slapped in jail, as well as being forced into exile). Voltaire’s works broadened the writing of history, including economy and culture, as well as war and politics.
Figure SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1JEAN-ANTOINE HOUDON, Voltaire in Old Age, 1781. Marble, height 20 in.
He criticized French politics and the intolerance of the Catholic Church, and in fact, he moved to England and then traveled abroad comparing foreign customs with the decaying “Old Regime” in France portrayed in his “Letters Concerning the English Nation”, as well as “Essay on Manners”, a universal history that examines the customs of foreign nations. No other Philosophes showed interest in the traditions of non-Western cultures more than Voltaire (admired the ethical teachings of Confucius). Voltaire remains also renown for becoming a councilor of great kings: he lived in Frederick’s II palace at Potsdam, and became the personal advisor of the king of Prussia, and kept a nourished correspondence with Catherine the Great of Russia, directing many of the empress’s reforms. Finally Voltaire was renowned for his tolerance and his aversion for religious wars and intolerance. In his “On Tolerance”, he explains how tolerance becomes a product of natural law, stimulated by a true case in France regarding a protestant merchant Jean Calais, which was falsely believed to have tortured and murdered his son that threatened to convert to Catholicism.
First and foremost, what Voltaire championed was freedom of thought, including the freedom of being absolutely pessimistic. This pessimism is directed against the “irrational” – so Voltaire interprets it – optimism of thinkers like Alexander Pope and Karl Leibniz. Voltaire’s pessimism remains immortal in his satires.
Candide hastened further to another village duirng the Thirty Years' War
His best satirical masterpiece, and maybe unprecedented in the world is Candide (subtitled optimism) Reading 25.4, a satire that attacks human optimism, that is, that a benevolent God could have only created a perfect world absent of evil and hatred. Voltaire’s attacks are directed mainly at the optimism of the Catholic Church and Christian institutions. This opera describes the exploits of a youthful simple man
Candide (literally frank), whose typical optimism – making him blind of the existence of evil – is struck by a series of terrible and hilarious experiences until he realizes the folly of believing “that all is for the best in this best of all possible worlds”. Candide had been taught so by Pangloss (all tongue, and representing Leibniz), the intellectual teacher of Candide that in the beginning teaches him optimism and that “whatever is, is right, because it is part of a plan”. Candide experiences the horrors of war (Thirty Years’ War); the evils of religious fanatism (inquisition, see Ch. 6 in Reading 25.4); the disasters of nature (the Lisbon earthquake); and the horrible effects of greed (nobility). Voltaire’s skepticism is clear: it is Voltaire’s answer to blind optimism and the foolish hope that God can justify (allay) evil. Voltaire explains this by ending his tale with Candide settling in a farm in turkey and telling his friend Pangloss that “we must cultivate our garden”, a metaphor indicating that pursuit of personal satisfaction is justified by a hostile world.
In fact, although Canidide survives his adventures – a testament of human resilience – and eventually finds and marries his love Cunegonde, the books conclusion with his famous statement, “we must cultivate our own garden”, can be seen also in another mode. We must, in other words, give up our naïve belief that we live in the best of all possible worlds, tend to small things that we can do well – thus keeping total pessimism at bay – and leave the world at large to keep on its incompetent, evil, and even horrific way. The conclusion of the satire shows the “absurdity” of optimism in Voltaire’s thought: Ch. 28, as they are sailing towards Turkey, Voltaire writes, “Well my dear Pangloss,” said Candide to him, “when you were hanged, dissected, whipped, and tugging at the oar, did you continue to think that everything in this world happens for the best?” “I have always abided by my first opinion,” answered Pangloss, “for after all, I am a philosopher…”
Excerpt from Voltaire’s Candide Theses and Erasmus’s “Praise to Folly – see excerpts Candide
Ancient Egypt: The Hymn to Aten and Hebrew Psalms (104)
It’s known that in three thousand years Egyptians worshipped a pantheon of more than 2000 deities. At times some were exhorted over the others, and deities were blurred or combined. Throughout most of Egyptian polytheist creed, the sun God, Amon Ra, had been the leader of this pantheon. However, during the eighteenth dynasty, a radical change happened, anticipating monotheismThe Hymns to Aten is a solemn lyrical poem, written by an Egyptian Pharaoh during the New Kingdom that is used to praise the divine power of a God. It still ranks as one of the most exquisite pieces of literature during the New Kingdom. Written by the Pharaoh Amenhotep IV (1353-1337), the father of Tutankhamen, it can be viewed inscribed in the tombs of many of his successors. The hymn to Aten marks a radical departure from traditional Egyptian belief, which, throughout the centuries had been thoroughly polytheistic, with the leadership given to the God Amon Ra. But toward the end of the eighteenth-dynasty, the Pharaoh Amenhotep IV gave way to one of the most important crisis in Egyptian history. He undertook a religious reformation, and fifteen years after his death his name was damned, his body scattered and his city leveled to the ground.
King Akhenaton and his wife, Queen Nefertiti, enjoying time with three of their six daughters under the sun disk God, the Aten. Sunken Carved Alabaster.
He is believed to have been the first monotheist, eliminating the existence of all other Gods except the solar disk god the Aten. He proclaimed the Aten his own deity, addressing the god as the soul god, the god in question was one. Therefore Amenhotep IV abolished the pantheon of Gods and established a monotheistic religion in which the sun disk Aten was worshipped exclusively. Other gods were still acknowledged, but they were considered to be too inferior to Aten to be worth worshipping. This type of monotheism is known as“henotheism.” Amenhotep’s new religion might have influenced the Hebrews that were arriving in that area during the 17th C. BCE. Amenhotep believed the sun was the creator of life, and he was so dedicated to Aten that he changed his own name to Akhenaten (“The shining Spirit of the Aten”) and moved the capital from Thebes to a site many miles north that he also named Akhenaten. This move transformed Egypt’s political and cultural as well as religious life. At this capital he presided over the worship of Aten as a divine priest and his queen as a divine priestess (Nefertiti). Temples to Aten were open courtyards, where the altar received the sun’s direct rays.
akhenatenColossusMany Egyptologists argue that the Pharaoh’s switch from polytheism to monotheism, quite clear in the hymn to Aten, was meant to enhance the power of the Pharaoh over a growing number of independent local temple priests who were menacing the centrality of the pharaoh.
The statue of Amenhotep IV (Akhenaton) in a strange new-fangled guise: an androgynous style with long, exaggerated bone structure, a long face, swollen belly and hips, and feminine-looking breasts. manifestation of some congenital pathology for example Marfan’s or Froelich’s syndrome. The Egyptian royal family had also been interbreeding for generations, and (the most famous Amarna mummy that has come down to us—Tutankhamun, very likely Akhenaten’s son—is loaded with congenital problems, including scoliosis, cleft palate, and club foot.)
With the pharaoh representing the one god that mattered, all religious justification for the power held by priesthood dedicated to the traditional gods, was gone. With the only sun disk god Aten as supreme god, embodying the characteristics of all other gods, this rendered them superfluous. By analogy Akhenaten was now supreme priest, rendering all other priests superfluous as well. Simultaneously, the temples dedicated to the other gods lost prestige and influence. These changes also converted the priests into dissidents. Akhenaten and his family worshipped the disk god, his subjects worshipped him. The reform, more than beingmonotheisticwas egocentric, only its intolerance was monotheist.
In brief, the Hymn to Aten is a ritual hymn of renewal and of constant creation. It emphasizes the Egyptiannotion of dualism and of universal balance between different forces.
Some scholars see a similarity between the Hymn to Aten and the Hebrew psalm. 104. In fact, some scholars argue that his religious reforms may have had a formative effect in the development of monotheism on the Hebrews, many of whom were perhaps enslaved in Egypt at the time of Akhenaten’s reforms. The style and subject of Psalm 104 bear a striking resemblance to the king’s hymn to the Aten.
Principal Egyptian Gods
Name
Role
Depicted As
Amon
sun god, creator of heaven and earth
falcon, sun rays
Anubis
patron of embalmers, god of cemeteries
jackal
Aten
god of the solar disk
solar disk
Bes
helper of women in childbirth, protector against snakes
lion-faced dwarf
Hapi
god of the Nile
bull
Hathor
mother, wife, and daughter of Ra, sky goddess
cow
Horus
son of Isis and Osiris, sky god
falcon
Isis
wife of Osiris, mother of Horus, fertility goddess
female
Maat
goddess of truth and universal order
head-feather
Osiris
god of the underworld
mummified king
Ptah
creator of humans, patron of craftspeople
mummified man
Set
brother of Osiris, god of storms and violence
pig, ass, hippopotamus
Thoth
inventor of writing, patron of scribes
ibis
Excerpt from Akhenaton’s Hymn to Aten – see excerpts Hymn to Aten
Prose. Overview Christianity and Buddhism: Prose, Sermon of the Mount; Sutra on Abuse
The earliest narratives regarding a prominent, eloquent, charismatic Jewish rabbi preacher named Jesus (Greek) or Joshua (Hebrew) appear in 70AD and will continue to be written until 100AD. This message became the basis for a new religion that will color the Middle Ages: Christianity. These testimonials were written or orally transmitted (as we know, Jesus’ sayings were also transmitted word of mouth) of some of his most renown disciples: Mark, Luke, Matthew, John – the Evangelist (in the arts they appear as winged figures). These accounts are known as the “Gospels”, literally “Good News”, one of five parts composing theNew TestamentThe Gospels are the statements of teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, written so that such teachings would not be lost. They indicate that Jesus was born in Palestine around 4-8AD, and that he was crucified during Tiberius’s reign. They tell us that he was born a Jew and that he will remain a Jew, and that he had stoutly said that he hadn’t come to lead a revolution if succession from Judaism, but one of reform and fulfillment.
The Message of Jesus: It’s true, there are no historical accounts contemporary to Jesus. All New Testament sources were written decades after the appearance of Jesus. They were written in Greek for non-Jews, and truly don’t reflect the situation immediately after Jesus’ death.
Orans (praying figure), ca. 300. Fresco. Catacombs of Saint Priscilla, Rome. The figure is shown here wearing the Jewish prayer shawl known as the tallis (or tallit).
It was in a divided land, characterized by civil dispute and hatred that Jesus started to preach. He preached the love of one God for all people; he preached to the poor, the simple, the weak, the sick, the outcasts. His preaching brought to us an enormous quantity of literature. From the books of his disciples – the Gospels, written in Greek – we learn what he said. He spoke of his father in heaven, and thought that he was themessiah that God had sent to earth to redeem humanity from sin. The rewards for a humble, honest life are the eternal joys of the afterlife in heaven: this he offered to all regardless of class status and race. Jesus was also known as the Christ – from the Greek Cristo (Christ, the anointed one). He was baptized by John in the Jordan river and all his followers required the same form of initiation. Jesus’ message is based on the following principles; 1- he gives more importance to faith and love an individual has towards God than to ritual activity; 2- he emphasis more the moral and ethical intentions of an individual than outward ritual behavior; 3-he offers a stern but loving, caring, understanding God, a God of mercy and pity ready to grant forgiveness through the sacrifice of his own son; this is not a judicial, inaccessible, remote, punishing God sitting on a throne with the Decalogue in his hands. The Sermon on the Mount recorded in Matthew’s Gospel summons the basic principles of Jesus’ reformation
The Good Shepherd, ca. 300. Marble, height 3 ft. (The legs are restored.) One of the most common images of Jesus in Early Christian art shows him as a youthful figure holding a lamb on his shoulders, a theme illustrating the parable of the Good Shepherd
Jesus’ thought aroused alarm and hostility among Jewish authorities. Both Sadducees and Pharisees mistrusted all reforming movements. When the Roman governor Poncius Pilate – to bring order – brought Jesus under trial and the latter responded that he was the Messiah, the Romans mistranslated Jesus’ expression as “King of the Jews”, therefore it was the political implication in Jesus’ answer that was the factor of fatality, the only implication that the Romans found punishable, the religious factor. The cruxification became the act of redemption for the Christian faith: Jesus had died for everyone. His followers said that he rose from the dead and would return for the final day of judgment.
Did he break Mosaic Law? 1- Accused merchants of blasphemy; 2- “I will rebuild the Temple”; 3- Forgave sin, only God can; 4- convened with the unclean and prostitutes; 5- got rid of blood sacrifice; 6- Worked on Saturday.
Sermon on the Mount, Matthew’s Gospel:
The gospel was probably written in the last decades of the first Century C.E. It incorporates many traditionalJewish teachings, and Jesus’s primary source is his Judaism. The sermon contains Jesus’ most famous sayings, Lord’s Prayer – itself a kind of collage of passages from the Hebrew Scriptures – and it differentiates, particularly, between accepted wisdom (“You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy…”) and the compassionate wisdom of new faith (“But I say to you so that you. Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven”). It is, furthermore, a masterpiece of rhetorical persuasion.
For example, in the The fulfilment of the Law, Jesus clearly states his aversion to break from Hebrew truth but at the same times, reveals his will to perfect it: “Do not imagine that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets. I have come not to abolish but to complete them.”
Excerpt from The Gospel of Matthew – see excerpts Sermon on the Mount
The Buddha and the sutra on Abuse:
Against the worldly creed of Hinduism that dominated India, there gradually rose – within Hinduism itself - a new religion based on the teachings of a sagacious, eloquent, ascetic Indian priest named Siddhartha Gautama (560-480BC); due to his righteous life, his exemplary morality and virtue, they called him theBuddha, the “Illumined One”. As Christianity began to win converts within the Roman Empire, the message of Buddha swept throughout Asia as well. The parallels – similarities – between both religions are remarkable, and both religions played a formative role in the cultural aspects of East and West.
The Buddha:
Born probably in the 560s BC into a rich Hindu family in the Indus river valley, Siddhartha was well educated and enjoyed a sumptuous life, free from pain and despair. He married a cousin at 19, fathered a child, but as he matured he came to realize how the lives of people – rich or poor – were always troubled by pain and anxiety. His discovery of the Three Truths” of existence – sickness, old age, and death – led him at 29 to renounce to wealth, abandon his wife and child, and begin quest for illumination.
Seated Buddha, from the Gandharan region of northwest Pakistan, ca. 200 c.e. Gray schist, 4 ft. 3 in. × 31 in. Born into India's princely Shakya clan, the Buddha was known as Shakyamuni, “sage of the Shakyas.” He is shown here wearing the simple robes of monk; his elongated earlobes are a reference to his princely origins. The iconic Buddha-pose is a study in
psychic self-containment.
He shaved his head, wore a yellow robe, barefoot and begging with a bowl, embraced ascetics, and toured India. After 6 years of Hindu ascetic life he concluded that total self-denial was useless. Turning inward he looked for a “middle path” of salvation, sitting under a fig tree and practicing meditation to reach the enlightenment.
The message of Buddha is found in the Book of Dharma (Book of teaching or righteous living); in it, meditation led Siddhartha to the full perception that the cause for human suffering was desire, that is, the attachment to material things that creates illusion. The Nirvana for the Buddha is the ultimate release from illusion and from the wheel of rebirth. Furthermore, as in Hinduism, Buddhism accepts the general Brahman belief of dividing the world into evil-doers and virtuous individuals, but it finds salvation in a different “Nirvana” – the peaceful release from the chain of earthly births and rebirths by living a life based on good works, charity and ascetic life. Finally, as Jesus will later on imply, Buddha’s message is based on equality, everyone can reach the Nirvana regardless of cast hierarchy, therefore, offering salvation to all.
The Buddha speaks about the 4-Noble Truths 1- Pain is Universal; 2- desire causes pain; 3ceasing to desire relieves pain 4- right conduct leads to release from pain. This can be obtained by following the Middle Way, or the Eightfold Path (see book). Differently from Christianity however, the Buddhist reward is not immortality, but to end reincarnation (the rebirth of the soul into different animal form): the release form the endless cycle of death and rebirth.
Enlightenment, detail of frieze showing four scenes from the life of the Buddha: Birth, Enlightenment, First Preaching, and Nirvana, from the Gandharan region of northwest Pakistan, Kushan dynasty, late second–early third century. Dark gray-blue slate.
Like Jesus, the Buddha was an eloquent teacher. And just like Jesus criticized Judaism’s heavy emphasis on ritual, so Buddha attacked the forms of Hindu worship; such as animal sacrifice and the caste system of the book of VedasIn this sense both religions – Buddhism and Christianity – were products of reformation of older world faiths: Hinduism and Judaism.
The Buddha himself never wrote nothing, but his disciples memorized his teachings and wrote them down in the 1st C. BC. in three main books known as the Pitakas “Baskets of Law”. The Pitakas were divided into instructional chapters known as “Sutra” (comparable to the sermons in Christianity). The Sermon on abuse remains emblematic and building a parallel with Christianity: Buddha’s regard for loving and caring guarantees the return of good from evil – a concept found in the Sermon on Abuse.
Excerpt from Buddah’s Sermons – see excerpts Sermon on Abuse
Similar sayings between Buddha and Jesus: press ctrl + click on the following link:
HYPERLINK "http://www.malibuchronicle.com/excerpts-from-jesus-and-buddha-the-parallel-sayings-by-beth-maire-from-the-book-edited-by-marcus-borg/http://www.malibuchronicle.com/excerpts-from-jesus-and-buddha-the-parallel-sayings-by-beth-maire-from-the-book-edited-by-marcus-borg/
Prose. Overview Islam: Excerpts from the Koran; The Thousand and One Nights
General Principles (Arabia, Bedouin life, pre-Islamic religion);
In the early seventh century AD, in the Middle East, we have the rise of a newly arrived monotheist faith, Islam, that from Arabia, will spread strongly into the Eastern and Western world, determining the intellectual character of the Middle Ages, with its enormous contribution in the arts, philosophy, and especially the applied sciences, as well as being the natural economical and cultural venue between the East and the West.
Islam, Submission to god, is the most recent of the monotheist creeds. Its adherents are known as Muslims, those who submit to God. And today Muslims inhabit the entire North African coast, major portions of Western and central Africa, the former Yugoslavian confederation, Ethiopia, Egypt, turkey, Central Asia and the entire Middle East. (see map 4.3, pg. 112 in text)
Arabia was the birthplace of the Islamic religion. The leader of Islam is Muhammad, the “Prophet”, the “Praised One”, he is not worshipped as a God, but respected as a Prophet. Arabia is a peninsula, a million square mile “wasteland”, practically devoid of any kind of marketable resource: Arabia was large, poor, hostile, and hot. Before the birth of Muhammad in the late sixth-century, it was inhabited by nomadic Arabic caravan trading tribes; Bedouin tribes, each one representing an independent society, each one under its own chieftain, Arabia was politically fragmented. Arabia was therefore a culturally isolated and underdeveloped region before the arrival of Islam. In the south-western corner of the peninsula, relatively fertile, several Arabic Kingdoms flourished. These kingdoms lived by the domestication of camels and trade in frankincense and spices, creating a commercial network of kingdoms, reaching as far as the Byzantine Empir(that controlled Asia Minor and Egypt), as well as the Persian Sassanid Empire (controlling also Mesopotamia), as well as Christian Ethiopia. It is from Byzantium and Ethiopia that Christian ideology – which played a relevant role in influencing the idea of monotheism – arrived. It is also known that Jewish colonies were also present in the southern parts of Yemen.
These Bedouin kingdom tribes were extremely mobile, lived by trade but also raid, the term “Arab”, is a Semitic term meaning “on the move”. The Bedouin of the 7th C. didn’t have a highly structured religious system. They apparently looked at life as a brief time during which to take full advantage of its pleasures.Ideas of an afterlife were not well defined. They Bedouins were pagan and animist; they worshipped a large number of gods and spirits, drawn from their natural surroundings, especially stones. Each tribe had its own Gods.
The two major cities in Arabia were Mecca and YatribThe former was the most important location in Arabia, located in the rising desert mountains of the region of Higiaz (meaning barrier), approx. 50 miles from the Red Sea. It was the most important center of commerce, trade, culture, and religion. Prior to Islam, the Mecca revealed the practice of a polytheist religion not so different from other Semitic people. Moreover, Mecca lay astray the most important trade routes, contributing to its relative stability and wealth.
The Kaaba, Mecca, Saudi Arabia. According to Muslim tradition, the Kaaba was built by Abraham and his son Ishmael; it is also said to mark the sacred spot where, at God's command, Abraham had prepared to sacrifice his son, Isaac.
Most important, was its function of acting for the most important religious sanctuary, the Ka’ba (the “cube”).The Ka’aba is a cube 48’x48’x48’, believed by the Muslims to have been built by Abraham, and where he prepared to sacrifice his son Isaac. Actually, before the rise of Muhammad, frequent Bedouin tribes worshipped a multitude of Gods and Goddesses (more than 360). Finally, the Ka’ba created an environment that was quite favorable and safe for commerce.
Inside the Ka’ba we find a prestigious stone (believed to have fallen from heaven), the Black Stone (maybe a meteorite), representing the God Hubal (which, ironically, was called by the pagan Bedouins, Allah – “the God”). Altogether, the Sacred Stone and the Ka’ba contributed in giving the city a great religious importance, which culminated with a ceremonial pilgrimage, of Pan Arabic value. Prior to Islam, it was known as the Umra, and followed by rotating around the Ka’ba known as the Tawaf, and a final pilgrimage – known as Hagg, to the close mountain of Arafa. In the 6th century this center was dominated by the Quraysh tribe, a trading people that lived by caravan commerce. They were an aristocracy of merchants and protectors of the Ka’ba and the Black Stone. In fact, the Quraysh were spectacularly rich due to the fact that they had Bedouins pay tribute to worship this sacred shrine, allowing them to worship a multitude of Gods. This process ensured a continuoussource of revenue for the merchants of the city.
Muhammad: Into this environment at Mecca was born Muhammad, actually, from one of the Quraysh clans, in 570AD. He was an early orphan (6 years old), his father Abdullah, died before his birth, his mother Aminashortly after. He was then raised by his uncle, Abu Talib, a prominent merchant of Mecca. He had little formal education, and his early years were spent helping his uncle in the caravan trade. He then entered the services and favors of a prominent woman of the Mecca, Khadija, her major business was caravan trading, and married her. She was about 15 years his senior, and she gave birth to 4 children, the most important of all was his daughter, Fatima, that played a an important role in the future of the Islamic state. The founts of information that we have of his life are two: the Koran (Recital), the sacred text of Islam; and the immense collections of traditions, “Hadits” (narrative), formed a few centuries after. The most ancient compilations of Hadits is known as the “sira” (model life), written by Ibn Ishaq, in the early 7th C.
Kufic calligraphy from the Qur'an, from Persia, ninth–tenth centuries. Ink and gold leaf on vellum, 8½ × 21 in. Qur'ans, like the holy books of Judaism and early Christianity, were usually handwritten on sheepskin (parchment) or calfskin (vellum) and han Kufic calligraphy from the Qur'an, from Persia, ninth–tenth centuries. Ink and gold leaf on vellum, 8½ × 21 in. Qur'ans, like the holy books of Judaism and early Christianity, were usually handwritten on sheepskin (parchment) or calfskin (vellum) and hand-decorated or “illuminated”—that is, ornamented with gold leaf or gold paint and brightly colored pigments. Arabic script, like Hebrew script, is read from right to left. Kufic calligraphy is notable for its angularity and its horizontal extensions.
Void of information is the life of Muhammad between his wedding to Khadica and the descent of the Koran upon him; it’s very probable that he was a pagan during these years. Nevertheless, it’s very probable that during his voyages for commercial reasons, he had reached Jerusalem several times and came into contact with the teachings of both Christianity and Judaism which must have infatuated him more than the primitive pagan beliefs of his own Mecca. Muhammad might have been driven by a sense of reforming not only the pagan traditions of Mecca, which he saw as irreligious and materialistic, but also Judaism and Christianity; in fact, he spent many days in vigils and fasting in a small cave of Mount Hira. There, finally, at the age of forty, in 610, Muhammad believes that God is revealing the truth to him, commanding him the seventh and last prophet to spread the last word of god. This word was spelt in Arabic. Muhammad therefore, is the new messenger, the prophet, the seal of god, he is the last prophet. Muhammad heard a call, coming from heaven, in the form of a command: “Recite!, In the name of the Lord, who created all things, who created man from a clot [of blood]. Recite! And your lord is the most Bounteous Who teaches by the pen, Teaches man that which he would not have otherwise known.” (Koran 96:1-5) It’s said that when Muhammad received revelations he would fall in a state of intense fever and cold, telling his followers to wrap him in a mantel; “Zammiluni! Zammiluni!”
Hence, the entire body of revelations is known as the Qur’an – the recital – one of the world’s most perfect literary productionswritten in perfect well balanced rhymed Arabic prose. It was devolved by Allah (the God), through Gabriel and imposed on Muhammad. Imposed, because in the beginning, when Gabriel unraveled a fine silken cloth with the writings of God, Muhammad was reticent in obeying to the Archangel’s orders. Hadits narrate that Muhammad was almost “strangled” by the silken cloth, until he agreed to read. Therefore, the Koran is the direct and infallible word of God. “Muhammad”, commanded Gabriel, “you are the Prophet of Allah and I am Gabriel!” In reality, Islam diverges in the interpretation of how he had received the Qur’an, had he memorized it all at once (in verbatim), or will he receive it in parts during the next 20 years!
Gabriel encounters Muhammad revealing the written words of Allah through the Koran.
One point is clear, he was and remained an unlettered man, he didn’t write the Koran. To call Muhammad the author of the Qur’an is considered blasphemous for all Muslims. Islam believes, then, that God had spoken several times prior to Muhammad; through Abraham, Moses, Samuel, Christ, but his message has been distorted or forgotten. The chapters of the Qur’an are not arranged chronologically, but by subject: chapters are known as “Surahs” (steps), there are 114, and they all start with the Bismillah“In the name of Allah, the Beneficent, Ever Merciful.” Chapters are divided into verses, “ayas”, there are altogether 6000. The opening chapters are of the Mecca period, the closing of the Median period. One of the marvels of the Qur’an is thateach following chapter is proportionally shorter than the other one, until the last chapters are reduced to few and short sentences, from 287 in the first Ch. to only 3 the last ch. It’s almost as if you are going down a long flight of stairs and the steps become narrower and narrower (like an algorithm). The true Qur’an, hence,literally records God’s speech and can only exist in the Arabic in which Muhammad had received it. In Sura n.75: 16-18, Allah states, “You need not move your tongue too fast to learn the revelation. We ourself shall see to its collection and recital. When we read it, follow its words attentively.” One point is clear, Muhammad was a man, a spokesman for Allah (a microphone), and worked out no miracles. In simpler terms, God does everything, or better, the angel. Among the first converts were his wife, and his cousin, Ali, son of Muhammad’s uncle, Abu Talib.
*The Qur’an is never to be translated from the Arabic for the purpose of worship because it is believed that translation distorts the divine message. The Qur’an remains the basic document for the study of Islamic theology, law, social institutions, and ethics. It forms the core of Muslim scholarship, from legal and linguistic inquiry to scientific and technical investigation.
Five Pillars of Islam: The formal demands of Islam are known as the Five Pillars of Islam; they are not that demanding or hard to perform, they put the believer in direct contact with God, since in Islam there isn’t any organized Church or hierarchy of clergymen between God and man.
When Muslims pray together - Salat - they pray in a mosque.
Islam makes salvation an individual responsibility of the believer. It is a layman religion.
Five times a day a Muslim must pray towards the Mecca – Kiblah Mihrab – this prayer is known as salat – obligation to pray. Muslims are called to prayer by a Muezzin (screamer), from the top of a minaret (tower). Prayer can be said alone, at work, at home, or in a mosque.
During the month of Ramadan – when in 620 for one month, Muhammad receives the revelations of Allah – all Muslims are prohibited to eat, drink, smoke tobacco or practice sex from dawn to sun setting. This is known as“sawm.”
All Muslims must make alms to the poor – Zakat - at least 1/10 of their richness must go to those in wanting.The payment is a social and religious obligation to provide for the welfare of the Umma.
At least once in their life they must make a sacred pilgrimage to the Mecca, known as Hajj. This happens in the twelfth month of the Islamic year. It symbolizes the unity of the Umma and the equality of all believers regardless of race or class.
All Muslims must make the Profession of Faith (shahada)this makes him a Muslim; “I believe that Allah is only true God and Muhammad is his prophet.”
Islam and other Religions: We notice many similarities between Islam, Christianity and Judaism; all believe in the same God, all are monotheist, all believe that Abraham is the first prophet of monotheism, all believe in the afterlife. Muslims and Jews have similarities of their own; both can worship together or worship alone, they don’t require an ecclesiastical organization; both practice circumcision and also are distinguished by their similar dietary restrictions. Interesting are the similarities between Christians and Muslimsboth believe in the Final day of judgment (Qur’an, Sura 76:23-25), in hell (Qur’an, Sura 47:8-11), Christ, the Virgin Mary and the Virgin birth of ChristMuslims recognize Jesus as a great prophet, and refer to him as Isa ibn Maryam – Jesus, the son of Mary; Mary is the only woman mentioned in the Qur’an. Muslims believe that Jesus ascended to heaven following his death, however, they cannot accept him as the son of God, Allah is above having a son (Qur’an, Sura 5:75). In addition, Islam believes that only Jesus and Mary were born untouched by Satan. Even Muhammad had to be purified by angels before receiving prophet hood. There are, however, two concepts in Islam regarding Christ that make it impossible for a reconciliation with Christianity:
1.Muslims believe that Jesus asked God to save him from crucifixion, and that God answered his prayer by taking him directly to heaven, God would not allow one of his prophets to be killed.
2.The Original Sin: While Christianity teaches that sin was transmitted to Adam’s descendents, Islam teaches that all people are born fundamentally good with a natural inclination to believe in one God. This innocent free state is called “fitrah.” This reinforces free will, because, although a person is born without original sin, a person is vulnerable to committing sins and becomes accountable for them at the age of reason. Furthermore, the original sin, would justify Jesus as the Son of God, sent down by God to redeem humanity.
Sharia, the Islamic Law: To Muslims, nevertheless, Jews and Christians are all “People of the Book”, because they worship the Holy Scriptures, recognized by Islam as valid (Qur’an, Sura 5:68-69). The Qur’an, however, differently from the Old Testament and the bible – which represent commendations – represents instead, a series of civil laws, to be followed and respected in order to reach salvation; the Sharia. The Sharia in itself indicates the concept of “The Path to Follow”, or ethical conduct, it’s a blending of Qur’an sayings and the words of the prophet known as HaditsThe sharia gives believers a perfect pattern of human conduct and regulates every aspect of a person’s activities. Those who study, interpret, and administer Sharia are known as Ulama (those who know). These laws range from private and personal concerns to those involving thewelfare of the whole state. It emphasizes the patriarchal nature of the family and society.
Hijra: Muhammad started to preach to the people of the Mecca the belief in one single God; not surprisingly, the Quraysh authorities repudiated him scornfully and menaced to death. His message threatened their economic livelihoods. Without the tolerance for a multitude of Gods that the Ka’ba represented among Arabs,Mecca could not guarantee a safe environment for trade and richness for the Quraysh.
Muhammad during his flight to Medina in 622 A.D., an event known as the Hijra or Hegira. Mohammed arriving at the walls of Medina.
He was accused of being a magician, a poet, he spoke about resurrection and of the final day of judgment, viewed by the Quraysh as ridiculous and dangerous. Furthermore, a tough blow was the dearth of Abu Talib and his wife Hadiqa, in 619, which had guaranteed protection.
In 622, pilgrims from the city of Yahtrib – 200 miles north of Mecca – invited Muhammad to reach their city and settle violent disputes between Arabs and Jews. The residents of Yahtrib were somewhat familiar with monotheistic beliefs. The choice was made, the city of the Prophet would have been Yahtrib (al-Medina – the City of the Prophet). By accepting this invitation, Muhammad temporarily abandoned the Mecca in 622 with a group of followers – known as the first Muslim “Umma” community. The Umma established relations with the Medinan tribes, including Jewish and Christian residents. Those that did not accept Islam were allowed to continue their way of life. Ultimately the Prophet’s preaching came into conflict with the Jewish tribes, and they were expelled. In fact, Muhammad’s attempt to convert the Jews failed, in retaliation he ordered in 624 that henceforth prayers will be directed not towards Jerusalem but towards the Mecca.
This period is known as the Hijra “departure”. Thus, 622, marks the beginning of the official Islamic calendar, just what the birth of Christ is for the ChristiansIt’s based on the lunar cycles, the Muslim year is about 11 days shorter than the Christian year, resulting in a difference of three years per century.
Excerpt from the Koran – see excerpts Koran
Arab Literature: Arab Muslim contribution in the field of literature dominated the Middle Ages. The Koran is written in beautiful, balanced Arabic rhymed prose, and its study, recitation, and memorization contributed to a lively appreciation for literature. Muslim writers throughout the Middle Ages penned magnificent poetry as well as prose that celebrated love, beauty and the sensual life. Perhaps, the most famous literary opera was the tales of the Arabic nights. This widely admired collection of stories was set in Baghdad in the court of the most powerful man on earth, the Abbasid Caliph Harun al-Rashid, which will become one of its protagonists. These tales have delighted readers in the east and the west as well.
The Thousand and One Nights was composed between the 8th and 10th C. AD, and it brings together in theArabic tongue tales from Persian, Indian, Chinese, and Arab background.
A Thousand and One Nights FilmPoster.
The framework of all these tales is the opening tale, an Indian tale of the beautiful princess Scheherazade, which is the allegorical narrator of the opera. The princess risking her life, decides to marry the very jealous king of her realm, King Shahriyar who avenged his first wife’s adultery – she had been caught making love to one of his slaves while he was out on a hunting bout – that he fears female infidelity so much that he married virgins one day and beheading them the morning after their defloration. This is a deeply satisfying image of Islam’s images and relations to the concepts of life, death, and storytelling. Despite her father’s remonstranceto avoid this marriage, he was the king’s emir that beheaded the young women in the morning, she decides to marry the king, and to avoid her tragic fate she narrates to her husband impressive tales, and she carefully brings the story to a climax during the early lights of dawn. The king, anxious to know the ending, must have her survive one more day (1001 nights, an infinite number). Scheherazade keeps her own going, hence, by telling other lives and deaths – and prolongs it long enough to bear the king three sons and extended both their lifelines into another generation. The king, satisfied, abolishes this horrible law, and sheds tears for hisprevious behavior.
Princess Scheherazade narrating a tale to her husband king Shahriyar
The opera contains 250 tales some read throughout the west as well. Such as Alibaba and the 40 Thieves,Aladdin, and the adventures of Sinbad the sailor. Not only does it demonstrate the new social and active position of females, thanks to the sharia law, that gave women certainly more opportunities than what they experienced in Bedouin times, but the manner in which each tale loops, linking one story to the other resembles the regulating and repetitive principles of the Koran as well as their artwork.
Excerpt from the Thousand and One Nights – see excerpts Prince Behram and the Princess Al-Datma
See Power Points: Islam
You have viewed this topic
 
Last Visited Jan 31, 2016 3:18 PM
 Last sent to Binder on Jan 19, 2016 10:11 PM